How to Build a Top Performers Board From Your Creative Audit

Short answer: A top performers board is one visual page that shows the results of a creative audit from left to right: a directory with the rules you used, a retest list, your search term results, one column per winning concept with its true total spend and results, a "static blitz" of small but efficient statics, and a swipe area of winning images. You can build it in Milanote, on a whiteboard or in a spreadsheet. The tool matters less than the order, because the order is what lets anyone on the team read the audit in a few minutes.

The brands in the examples are made up. We use Cradlewell, a breathable, washable crib mattress, throughout.

What is a top performers board?

A top performers board is a single page that turns a lifetime creative audit into something you can see: every concept that carried real spend, its true total across all its copies, and the patterns those winners share.

The audit is the work: you look at the whole life of the account and add up every duplicate of each winning concept (see the lifetime creative audit). The board is where that work lands, instead of a spreadsheet nobody opens twice.

Why put an audit on a board instead of a spreadsheet?

Because creative is visual, and patterns jump out when you see the ads side by side. A sheet can tell you that a concept spent the most. A board shows you that your top five concepts all sit on a dark background, or all lead with one claim, and that is the thing that shapes your next brief. It also gives strategists, designers and media buyers the same answer to "what has worked here?"

What goes on the board, from left to right?

We build it in this order. Each part answers one question.

Part What it holds The question it answers
Directory The audit rules, total account spend, spend on the product audited, the goal, a link to the latest creative batch What did we look at, and against what bar?
Retest list Entry rules plus each concept to bring back, with ad name and file name What should we run again?
Search terms Each word searched in Ads Manager with its rolled up spend and ROAS Which ideas won or lost as a group?
Search term columns One column per word with spend, ROAS, purchases, number of ads, file name and a screenshot of the results What sits behind each word?
Concept columns One column per winning concept with its true totals and a preview Which single ideas carried the account?
Static blitz Small spend statics with very strong efficiency Which quiet winners never got a real budget?
Swipe area The winning statics placed together What do the winners look like as a set?

ROAS (return on ad spend) is revenue divided by ad spend. If you work to a CAC (customer acquisition cost) goal instead, use that in every column. Just use one measure across the whole board.

What goes in the directory column?

The directory holds the rules of the audit, so nobody has to guess what the numbers mean. Ours lists:

  1. Time period. All time, so the board reflects the whole life of the account.
  2. Campaign type. Evergreen, kept separate from promo and sale campaigns.
  3. Objective. Conversion campaigns only.
  4. Funnel. Prospecting to cold audiences as much as possible, so remarketing results don't flatter the ads.
  5. Goal. The ROAS or CAC bar a concept has to clear.
  6. Total spend and product spend. How much the account spent in its life, and how much of that went to the product you audited.
  7. Link to the latest creative batch. So the team can compare what worked before with what is being made now.

We explain why each rule matters in how to set the rules for a creative audit. The short version: if the rules change halfway, the board stops being comparable.

What goes in each concept column?

Each winning concept gets its own column with the same fields in the same order: concept name, total spend across all copies, ROAS, purchases, the number of ads it lives in, the file name and a preview.

Concept name is the ad name pattern you searched to find every copy. Number of ads is often the surprise. One winning idea can live in a dozen or more ads across campaigns and Ad Sets, which is why a single ad rarely looks like the top performer until you add its copies up. Our guide to finding every version of a winning ad covers how to do that without double counting.

File name (or creative ID) lets a designer find the asset fast. Preview is a screenshot, so nobody needs to open Ads Manager.

Order the columns from the largest total spend to the smallest. The goal is to cover most of the account's spend with a small set of concepts, usually 10 to 15. When the columns stop adding meaningful spend, stop adding columns.

On Cradlewell, the concept columns might read: a static that leads with one claim ("100% breathable and washable"), a press quote static, a "how it's made" video paired with an offer, a split screen video of parents talking about the mattress, and a customer hype carousel.

What are the search term columns for?

Search term columns group ads by idea instead of by name. You type one word into the Ads Manager search, such as "breathable" or "waterproof", note the rolled up results, and give that word its own column.

Each column holds the word's rolled up spend, ROAS, purchases, number of ads, a file name for the best example and a screenshot of the Ads Manager results, so anyone can check what the word caught.

This is where angle level lessons show up. On Cradlewell, a price led "cheap" angle might lose money as a group, while a claim led "breathable" angle clears the bar. A small term like "POV" might have very little spend but strong results, which makes it a retest candidate. Our guide to auditing by angle with search terms goes deeper.

What is the static blitz?

The static blitz is a column of statics that spent very little but returned very well. These are low frequency winners: ads that only had a handful of conversions because they never got a real budget.

Their totals are too small for the concept columns, but too good for the trash. They go in the static blitz so the team can relaunch them together at a real budget. The retest list explains how we decide what makes the cut.

Why include a swipe area?

The swipe area puts the winning statics next to each other so you can see what they share. Patterns that hide in columns become obvious in a grid: the same dark background, the same single claim in large type, the same parent and baby image, the same color swapped three ways.

On Cradlewell, the swipe area might show that the same image ran on yellow, coral and dark green backgrounds and all three made the top group. That is a color test worth repeating on the next winner. Turning those patterns into new work is covered in how to turn a creative audit into your next brief.

Which tool should you use?

Use whatever your team will actually open. Each option has a trade off.

  • Milanote (or a similar visual board tool) is what we use. Columns, images and notes sit together and the board is easy to share with a client or a designer.
  • A whiteboard works for a team in one room. It is fast to build, but hard to keep and share.
  • A spreadsheet is the easiest to sort and filter. Add a preview image column, or link each row to a screenshot, so it doesn't lose the visual side.

Whatever you pick, keep the same left to right order every time.

How long does it take to build?

It used to take us hours and hours, mostly hunting for every copy of each winning ad. A clean ad naming convention cuts that sharply, because one search returns every copy of a concept.

Key takeaways

  • A top performers board turns a lifetime creative audit into one page anyone on the team can read.
  • Build it left to right: directory, retest list, search terms, search term columns, concept columns, static blitz, swipe area.
  • Every concept column uses the true total across all copies, not the single best ad.
  • Search term columns show which angles win or lose as a group.
  • The static blitz holds small but efficient statics that never got a real budget.
  • The tool matters less than keeping the same order every time.

FAQ

How many concept columns should a top performers board have? Usually 10 to 15. The aim is for that small set to cover most of the account's spend. If adding a column no longer adds meaningful spend, you have enough.

Should video and statics go in separate sections? Keep them in the same concept columns, ordered by spend, so you can compare formats directly. The swipe area is where statics get their own grid, since that is where visual patterns are easiest to spot.

How often should the board be rebuilt? Rebuild it with each new lifetime audit, a few times a year for most accounts. Add new winners as they prove themselves.

Can I build a board for one product only? Yes, and in most accounts you should. Audit one product line at a time and note the product's share of total spend in the directory, so results from different products don't blur together.

Want a second set of eyes on your creative?

We'll look at what has carried your account and what is worth bringing back, for free. You get a full account audit plus net new reach and cumulative reach reports. Request it on our contact page.

Check what you learned

Tap an answer to see if you got it right.

1. What is a top performers board?

Anyone on the team can read it.

2. What does each concept column use?

Totals, not highlights.

3. What's the static blitz?

They deserve a real test.

Ready for the full test? Take the Creative Audit exam and get certified. Want this run on your account? Get my free audit.

About the author

Jake Mehani, founder of Creative Analytics

Jake has spent 15 years running Meta and paid social ads for consumer brands. Meta published his RBX Active Advantage+ case study, he taught the DMAnc Meta and TikTok ads masterclass, and he spoke at Motion's 2024 Creative Strategy Summit. His senior team runs media buying, creative and measurement like an in house team.

Jake on LinkedIn  |  Case studies  |  Free Meta audit

Previous
Previous

The Retest List: Which Old Meta Ads to Bring Back (and the Static Blitz)

Next
Next

Audit by Angle: How to Use Ads Manager Search Terms to Group Ads by Idea