Short answer: Before you rank a single ad, decide what counts. We set the time period (all time), the campaign type (evergreen, not promo), the objective (conversions), the funnel stage (prospecting or cold traffic as much as possible), the ROAS or CAC goal, the product line being audited, and a spend floor. These rules keep you comparing like with like, so the winners you find are real.
The brands in the examples are made up. Our running example is Cradlewell, a breathable, washable crib mattress.
Why does a creative audit need rules?
Without rules, an audit compares things that should never be compared. A Black Friday ad sitting next to an evergreen ad, or a retargeting ad next to a cold one, will look like a winner for reasons that have nothing to do with the creative.
Here is the problem. Ads Manager will happily rank everything together. A promo ad with a deep discount and a warm audience can show a ROAS (return on ad spend, revenue divided by spend) that no evergreen ad will ever match. If you include it, you learn that discounts to warm people work. You already knew that.
The solution is to write the rules down first, at the top of the audit, in what we call the Directory. Anyone reading the audit later can see exactly what was included and why.
What time period should a creative audit cover?
Use the account's full lifetime. A lifetime creative audit is about the ideas that built the account, and those ideas often stopped running long ago.
A short window only shows what is live now. The all time view brings back concepts that were switched off during a restructure, ads that ran well for a season and were forgotten, and concepts that were copied into so many places their true size was never clear.
If the account changed a lot (a new product, a big price change, a new site), note the date in the Directory. You may want a second, shorter view that starts after the change.
Should you include promo campaigns?
No. Keep the audit to evergreen campaigns, meaning campaigns that run all year at normal pricing.
Promo results are driven by the offer and the timing as much as the creative. A sale also pulls in people who were already going to buy. Mixing promo ads in makes average ideas look strong and makes your evergreen winners look smaller than they are. If you want to learn from promos, run a separate audit on promo campaigns only.
Which campaign objective should you audit?
Audit campaigns with a conversion objective, meaning Meta was told to find purchases (or leads, for a lead gen account).
Traffic, engagement and video view campaigns optimize for different things. An ad that wins on cheap outbound clicks in a traffic campaign tells you little about whether it sells. Keep the objective the same across every ad you rank.
Why audit prospecting and cold traffic only?
Because cold traffic is where creative has to do all the work. Restrict the audit to prospecting campaigns and Ad Sets as much as the account allows.
Retargeting ads reach people who already visited the site, added to cart or bought before. Their results lean on that existing interest, not on the ad. An idea can look great in retargeting and do nothing to find new buyers. That is the same reason we run creative testing to cold audiences, and why it is worth asking whether your remarketing is incremental at all.
In older accounts the line between cold and warm is often blurry, with broad Ad Sets that include past visitors. Get as close to cold as the account allows and note what you could not separate.
What goal should you judge concepts against?
Use the account's real ROAS or CAC goal (CAC is customer acquisition cost, what you pay to get one new customer). Write it in the Directory before you start.
A goal turns a list of numbers into a verdict. A concept that spent a lot under goal is a lesson, not a winner. A concept that spent little far above goal may belong on the retest list. If the goal changed over the years, use the one that reflects current margins, and say so.
Also decide which attribution setting you will read, such as 7 day click or 7 day click plus 1 day view. Keep it the same for every concept. Our attribution windows guide explains the difference.
Why audit one product line at a time?
Because different products have different prices, margins and buyers. Mixing them blurs every pattern.
Say Cradlewell sells a crib mattress and a much cheaper mattress protector. Protector ads will show different ROAS and different winning angles. Ranked together, the result describes neither product. Audit one product line at a time, and note in the Directory the account's total lifetime spend and how much of it went to that product, along with that product's goal.
What spend floor should you set?
Set a minimum spend a concept must reach before you judge it. Below the floor, results are mostly noise.
There is no single right number. A good floor is tied to your goal, usually a multiple of your target CPA (cost per acquisition) so a concept has had the chance to get several purchases. Bigger accounts can set it higher. Concepts under the floor are not ignored. The ones that were very efficient on small spend go to a separate list (we call it the static blitz) for a fair retest. More on that in the retest list.
What coverage target should the audit hit?
Aim for 10 to 15 concepts that together cover the large majority of the spend in scope. In most accounts that is an 80/20 split. In some it is closer to 95/5.
The coverage target tells you when to stop. Keep adding concepts, biggest first, until they cover most of the spend. If you need 40 concepts to get there, the account has no clear winners, and that is a finding in itself.
The rules at a glance
| Rule | What we use | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Time period | All time | Finds ideas that built the account, not just what is live |
| Campaign type | Evergreen only | Promos are driven by the offer and timing, not the creative |
| Objective | Conversions | Other objectives optimize for different actions |
| Funnel stage | Prospecting or cold, as much as possible | Warm audiences flatter weak creative |
| Goal | The account's ROAS or CAC goal | Turns numbers into a verdict |
| Product | One product line at a time | Prices, margins and buyers differ |
| Spend floor | A multiple of target CPA | Keeps noise out of the ranking |
| Coverage | 10 to 15 concepts covering most spend | Tells you when to stop |
What if the account breaks the rules?
Older accounts often mix cold and warm traffic in one Ad Set, or run promos inside evergreen campaigns. Do the best you can and write down every exception in the Directory.
A good audit is honest about its limits. "Prospecting only, except the 2023 broad Ad Sets, which included site visitors" is far more useful than pretending the data is cleaner than it is.
Key takeaways
- Write the audit rules down first, at the top of the audit, so everyone knows what was included.
- Use all time, evergreen campaigns, a conversion objective and cold traffic as much as possible.
- Judge every concept against the real ROAS or CAC goal with one attribution setting.
- Audit one product line at a time and note how much lifetime spend went to it.
- Set a spend floor tied to your target CPA, and send small but efficient ads to a separate retest list.
- Stop when 10 to 15 concepts cover most of the spend.
FAQ
Can I run a creative audit on just the last year? You can, but you will miss older winners that were switched off. Start with all time, then add a shorter view if the business changed a lot.
What if my account has no prospecting campaigns? Many accounts run broad Ad Sets that mix new and returning people. Use the most prospecting focused campaigns you have, and note that results may be flattered by warm traffic.
Should I use ROAS or CAC? Use whichever goal the business actually manages to. Subscription and high repeat brands often care more about CAC, while single purchase brands often use ROAS.
What do I do with ads below the spend floor? Leave them out of the main ranking. If any were very efficient on small spend, add them to the static blitz so they get a fair retest at real budget.
Want help setting up your first audit?
We'll review your account with these rules and show you which ideas really carried it, for free. You get a full account audit plus net new reach and cumulative reach reports. Request it on our contact page.
Check what you learned
Tap an answer to see if you got it right.
1. When do you set the audit rules?
2. Which traffic should you use as much as possible?
3. Which campaigns should be included?
Ready for the full test? Take the Creative Audit exam and get certified. Want this run on your account? Get my free audit.
Module 9: Creative Audit · article 2 of 8
Next: How to Find Every Version of a Winning Meta Ad and Its True Total
Previous: What Is a Lifetime Creative Audit? How to Find the Ads That Really Built Your Meta Account
About the author
Jake Mehani, founder of Creative Analytics
Jake has spent 15 years running Meta and paid social ads for consumer brands. Meta published his RBX Active Advantage+ case study, he taught the DMAnc Meta and TikTok ads masterclass, and he spoke at Motion's 2024 Creative Strategy Summit. His senior team runs media buying, creative and measurement like an in house team.