Short answer: Lay your winning concepts side by side and write down what they share: the type of claim, the proof they use, the format, the visual style and the offer. Then turn each pattern into two kinds of brief items: iterations of proven winners (new hooks, new formats, color and image tests) and new concepts built on the same patterns. Add the angles that lost to a "don't" list so they don't creep back in. The brief should read like a summary of what the audit proved, not a list of fresh guesses.
The brands in the examples are made up. Our main example is Cradlewell, a breathable, washable crib mattress.
Why start a brief from an audit?
Because the audit is the only place where your account tells you, with real money behind it, what your buyers respond to. A brief built from it starts with evidence. A brief built from a blank page starts with opinions.
Most teams brief from the last few weeks of results, or from what a competitor is running. Both are useful, but both miss the long view. A lifetime creative audit shows which ideas carried the account across years, and those ideas are usually still the strongest base for new work.
What should you look for in the audit?
Look for what the winners have in common, not just which ones won. One winner is a data point. Three winners that share a trait are a pattern you can brief.
Go through your top performers board and tag each winning concept on five things:
- Claim. What does the ad say the product does? One claim or several?
- Proof. What makes the claim believable? A press quote, a customer, a demo, a comparison?
- Format. Static, video, carousel, slideshow, split screen?
- Look. Background color, people in the frame, text size, product shown or not?
- Offer. Is there a discount, free shipping, a bundle, or no offer at all?
Then count. If most of your winners lead with one claim, that is your first brief line.
What patterns usually show up?
Every account is different, but these are the patterns we see most often when we audit, shown here on Cradlewell.
| Pattern | What it looks like on Cradlewell | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Claim led statics | "100% breathable and washable" in large type over the product | One clear claim beats a list of features |
| Press quotes | An "as seen in" static quoting coverage of the breathable, washable design | Outside voices make the claim believable |
| How it's made plus offer | A static and a video on how the mattress is built, paired with money off and free shipping | Showing the work earns the offer |
| Us vs Them | A slideshow video with a "safest" hook comparing Cradlewell to a standard mattress | Contrast makes the benefit obvious |
| Dark backgrounds | A dad holding a baby on a dark background | Mood and contrast stop the scroll |
| Color tests | The same top image on yellow, coral and dark green | Small visual swaps can each become winners |
| Customer hype carousel | Parents saying their babies sleep better, one quote per card | Real parents carry the emotional claim |
The losing patterns matter just as much. On Cradlewell, a price led "cheap" angle might lose money as a group. That goes on the "don't" list. Our guide to auditing by angle with search terms shows how to spot losing angles across many ads at once.
How do you turn a pattern into an iteration?
An iteration keeps what made a winner work and changes one thing. It is the safest part of any brief, because the idea is already proven.
For each top concept, pick the change that fits:
- New hook. For a winning video, rewrite or reshoot the first few seconds and keep the body. Our guide to iterating a winning video ad covers which parts to keep and which to change.
- New format. Turn a winning static into a short video, a carousel or a slideshow. Turn a winning video into a static built on its strongest line.
- New color or image. If color tests already won, run the same test on the next winner. If a dad and baby image won, test a mom and baby, or a newborn alone.
- New proof. Swap a press quote for a customer quote, or add an award to a claim led static.
We use a simple model for this: the four versions of every winning ad. Each winner can be remade in several ways before you need a new idea.
On Cradlewell, a brief section might read: "Breathable claim static: three new background colors, one version with the award badge, one version as a three card carousel."
How do you turn a pattern into a new concept?
A new concept uses a proven pattern with a new idea inside it. It carries more risk than an iteration, but less than a blank page guess.
Ask: "What other ad could follow this pattern?" If press quotes win, find coverage you haven't used yet. If Us vs Them wins, compare against a different alternative (a different kind of mattress, or the old way of cleaning one). Our guide to Us vs Them ads has more on building these. If customer hype carousels win, collect new quotes and build a carousel around a different benefit.
The creative playbook of ad formats is a good place to look for formats that fit a pattern you've found. For example, if claim led statics win, a feature callout grid is a natural next format to try.
What about video that needs creators?
When a winning video used a creator or a customer, the brief needs to say what to keep. Write down the beats that worked (the hook type, the order of the reasons, the length) and hand them to new creators in a creator brief.
On Cradlewell, our team flagged one winning couple testimonial as a strong base for a reverse testimonial voiceover, where the questions are written so the answers come out as natural selling points. Our guide to reverse testimonial questions explains how. Notes like that belong in the brief, next to the ad they came from.
How should the brief be laid out?
Keep it short and tied to the evidence. We use four sections:
- What won. The top patterns, each with one or two example ads from the audit and their file names.
- Iterations. For each top concept, the specific changes to make.
- New concepts. New ideas built on proven patterns, with the pattern named.
- Don't. The angles and styles that lost as a group, so they don't get made again by accident.
Link every item back to the ad or search term that justifies it. When someone asks "why are we making this?", the answer should be one click away.
How do you know the brief worked?
Test the new work like any other new ad: cold audiences, a fair budget and the same judging rules (see how a creative testing ad gets judged). Over a few rounds, compare how often audit based work wins against how often your old briefs did. Our guide to creative hit rate explains how to track that.
If iterations keep winning and new concepts keep losing, your patterns are right but your new ideas are drifting. Pull the next new concepts closer to what the audit showed.
Key takeaways
- Start a brief from the audit so it rests on what your buyers already proved.
- Tag winners on claim, proof, format, look and offer, then count what they share.
- Iterations change one thing about a proven winner: hook, format, color, image or proof.
- New concepts put a new idea inside a proven pattern.
- Add losing angles to a "don't" list so they don't creep back.
- Link every brief item to the ad or search term that justifies it.
FAQ
How many items should a brief built from an audit have? Enough for one round of testing in your account, which depends on your budget and how fast your team can produce. Most of the items should be iterations, with a smaller share of new concepts.
What if the audit shows only one or two winning patterns? That is common, especially in younger accounts. Brief deep on those patterns with many iterations, and add a few new concepts to find the next pattern.
Should the audit replace competitor research? No. Use both. The audit tells you what works for your buyers. Ad library research gives you new formats and structures to try those patterns in.
How often should we rebuild the brief from a fresh audit? Whenever you run a new lifetime audit, which for most accounts is a few times a year. In between, update the brief with new winners from each round of testing.
Want a second set of eyes on your creative?
We'll look at what has worked in your account and what your next brief should hold, for free. You get a full account audit plus net new reach and cumulative reach reports. Request it on our contact page.
Check what you learned
Tap an answer to see if you got it right.
1. Where should a brief start?
2. What is an iteration?
3. What goes on the 'don't' list?
Ready for the full test? Take the Creative Audit exam and get certified. Want this run on your account? Get my free audit.
Module 9: Creative Audit · article 7 of 8
Next: Meta Ad Naming Conventions: The Taxonomy That Makes Creative Audits Take Minutes
Previous: The Retest List: Which Old Meta Ads to Bring Back (and the Static Blitz)
About the author
Jake Mehani, founder of Creative Analytics
Jake has spent 15 years running Meta and paid social ads for consumer brands. Meta published his RBX Active Advantage+ case study, he taught the DMAnc Meta and TikTok ads masterclass, and he spoke at Motion's 2024 Creative Strategy Summit. His senior team runs media buying, creative and measurement like an in house team.