About this session: Module 2 of a two part Meta (Facebook and Instagram) and TikTok advertising masterclass that Jake Mehani taught for the Direct Marketing Association of Northern California (about 1 hour 47 minutes).
Short answer: This training teaches how to find a "creative unicorn," an ad that drives purchases or leads at your goal and at scale, and how to keep finding them. It covers the ad formats that keep working, modular content you can remix, how to get footage from customers, how to test new ads fairly, how to read video metrics in four stages, and the simple moves for iterating on an ad that is close to winning.
Session map: what this training covers
- The creative unicorn: what a winning ad really is and why iteration beats guessing.
- Formats that keep working: nine proven ad formats and how to build a creative playbook.
- Edutainment: hooks that tell the brain it is about to learn something.
- Modular content: recording footage in blocks so editors can remix without reshoots.
- Customer footage: a simple system for getting authentic video from real buyers.
- Scripting formulas: the two direct response structures behind almost every ad.
- Fair testing: why the algorithm hides good ads, and how runoffs fix it.
- Reading video ads: the four stages, and the fix for each one that breaks.
- Iterating on a winner: turning one great ad into many.
- Team setup: timelines, reviewers, sizes and ad libraries.
What is a creative unicorn?
A creative unicorn is an ad that drives purchases or leads at or below your cost goal, profitably and at scale. The whole session is about producing more of them. Jake's starting point: you rarely hit a home run with your first ad, but a near miss usually holds enough data to fix it. Improving an ad that is close is easier than starting over, which is why iteration is the core skill.
Which ad formats keep working?
Jake recommends every brand keep a creative playbook: a board where you save every ad that performed, grouped by format. Many formats have worked for years because they match how people like to take in information. Formats he walks through:
- Split screen. A customer tells their story on one side while the product is shown on the other, so viewers follow the story and see the product.
- Us versus them. Your product compared side by side with the usual alternative. Works for prospecting and remarketing.
- Feature call out. The product surrounded by its key selling points. Strong for food, beauty and fashion, and easy to turn into a static.
- Grid. Several products or angles in one frame, great for showing a range.
- Handwritten note. Feels personal, often stops the scroll, and works across many categories including B2B.
- Visual story. A simple illustrated story that explains a complicated service in a few frames.
- Green screen. A founder or customer talking over product images or the website. Easy to make and very effective when it comes from the heart.
- Meme with a call to action. The meme earns attention; a pop up turns it into a direct response ad.
- Comment response. A video answering a real or typical customer question or objection.
Jake's tip on message testing: almost nobody reads the text above an ad. If you want to say something, show it or say it inside the video.
What is edutainment, and how much should you use it?
Edutainment is content that is both educational and entertaining, like "3 reasons why" or "what I ordered versus what I got." These hooks tell the brain it is about to learn something, so they tend to stop the scroll. Jake's advice is to use them as part of the mix, not the whole program, and to watch TikTok for any storytelling format many people use at once, since that shows it is a format people enjoy.
What is modular content?
Modular content is ad footage recorded in separate blocks, like hooks, problem, solution, demo and testimonial, instead of one long linear take. An editor can then swap hooks, reorder blocks or cut weak sections without a reshoot. If an ad stops people but loses them in the middle, you can simply drop in a different middle block.
Jake suggests a content mix led by customers, followed by trending hooks from creators, with a small share left for experiments. Customer footage is the most authentic and the cheapest. The money you save on footage is best spent on great editors.
How do you get footage from customers?
- Wait until the return window has passed, so you only ask happy customers.
- Send an automated email with a short set of product questions and buying journey questions, such as when they realized they needed it and what they were doing when they found the solution.
- Ask them to record each answer as its own clip on their phone.
- Offer a simple thank you, like a gift card, and include clear permission to use the footage in ads.
- For the best performers, ask to run the ad from their own profile, which often lifts results because people trust people more than brands.
For creators, give a one page guide with a shot list, a set of hook options, talking points, and examples of ads you like. Good guidelines mean the footage arrives close to ready instead of needing many rounds of changes.
Which scripting formulas should every ad follow?
Two classic direct response structures sit behind almost every format in the session:
- Hook, then educate, demonstrate, inform, entertain. "Inform" means helping the viewer feel confident in their choice, even if your product is not the one for them.
- Problem, agitate, solution, testimonial. The structure of the classic as seen on TV commercial.
Jake also suggests researching scripts from your own best ads, post purchase surveys, reviews, Reddit and competitor ads, and using AI tools to summarize why people buy, framed around the needs behind the purchase.
How should you test new ads?
Meta and TikTok push budget toward the early leader in an Ad Set. That is efficient, but it means other ads that were also profitable get very little spend and never get a fair look. Jake's fix is a runoff test: duplicate the Ad Set without the winner and let the runners up compete on their own. Only do this for ads that showed real promise on reach, conversion rate and cost.
Give your testing budget enough room relative to your cost per purchase goal so the system can actually find buyers. When an ad has no purchases yet, use early signals such as cost per add to cart compared with your best ad before deciding to pause it.
For more on our current approach, see runoffs and how a creative testing ad gets judged.
How do you read a video ad's performance?
Jake breaks video analysis into four stages:
- Attention: stop rate, the share of impressions that watched at least three seconds (3 second video views divided by impressions).
- Interest: hold rate, how far viewers get into the video.
- Desire: click through rate. Use the most conservative version, such as unique outbound CTR.
- Action: conversion rate.
Then match the fix to the stage that is breaking:
- High stop rate, low hold: shorten the video, move the selling points earlier, or reorder blocks.
- Low stop rate, strong hold or conversion: the middle works; test new hooks.
- Strong stop and hold, weak clicks: rework the offer or swap the middle blocks.
- Strong everything except conversion: look at the landing page, price or offer.
Label every ad with its length so you can quickly turn percentages into seconds and see where people drop off.
How do you iterate on a winning ad?
Once you have a winner, Jake treats it as two assets: the footage and the story (the voiceover). Ways to extract more value:
- Test new hooks: different text, opening visual or voiceover.
- Put the winning voiceover over other footage, and the winning footage under other voiceovers.
- Record the same story with different people, including a male and female voice.
- Add reviews or other social proof.
- Make a green screen, reaction or comment response version.
- Turn the winning video into a grid or a static feature call out.
- Test different thumbnails.
He walks through one example where a single unboxing video became a grid version and then a holiday sale version, each built from the same core footage.
What else should teams set up?
- A short creative timeline. Customer content can go from footage to live in a couple of weeks once editors know the format.
- Few reviewers. One or two people give feedback. Too many opinions slow everything down.
- Frame by frame review tools so feedback is tied to the exact second it refers to.
- Correct sizes and safe zones for feed, stories and reels.
- Smart use of ad libraries. In Meta's Ad Library, a competitor ad that has been running the longest is usually their best one. Spend alone does not prove an ad is profitable.
The creative unicorn checklist
Use these questions before you brief, launch or kill an ad. They pull the whole session into one page.
- Is this format proven? Is it in your creative playbook, or are you guessing?
- Is the footage modular? Can an editor swap the hook or the middle without a reshoot?
- Who is talking? A real customer or a passionate founder usually beats a script read.
- Is the structure clear? Hook, then educate, demonstrate, inform, entertain, or problem, agitate, solution, testimonial.
- Is the product shown inside the video? Assume nobody reads the text above the ad.
- Did every promising ad get a fair test? If a runner up was close, give it a runoff.
- Which stage is breaking? Stop, hold, click or convert. Fix that one stage first.
- What is the next version? New hook, new voice, new footage, new format. One winner should become many ads.
Key takeaways
- A creative unicorn is a profitable ad at scale. You find them by testing and iterating, not by guessing right the first time.
- Keep a creative playbook of every format that has worked for you.
- Record footage in modular blocks so editors can remix without reshoots.
- Customers are the best and cheapest source of footage. Spend the savings on great editors.
- Read video ads in four stages and fix the one that is breaking.
- Give promising runners up a fair second test instead of letting them die in the shadow of the winner.
FAQ
What is a stop rate?
The share of people who stop scrolling on your video, measured as 3 second video views divided by impressions. A high stop rate does not guarantee sales, but if nobody stops, nobody sees the rest of the ad.
What is a runoff test?
A new Ad Set that tests the runner up ads from an earlier test without the winner, so ads that were close get enough spend to prove themselves.
What is modular content?
Footage recorded in separate blocks such as hooks, problem, solution and testimonial, so an editor can mix and reorder them into many versions.
How long should a video ad be?
As long as it stays interesting. Jake's view is that short length guidance mostly reflects weak content; a genuinely interesting story can hold attention much longer.
Keep reading
- The CTSG system: Creative Testing, Scaling and Graveyard
- Runoffs: picking between two close ads
- The four versions of every winning ad
- Writing a creator brief creators actually follow
Want your team trained on this? We train media buyers for in-house teams and agencies, and we offer a free Meta audit. Get in touch.
Ready for your free Meta audit?
We will review your account and run net new reach, cumulative reach and creative reach reports, free.