Watch the episode: The Creative Strategy Podcast with Jake Mehani on YouTube (about 64 minutes).
Short answer: In this episode, host Brett Friedman talks with Creative Analytics founder Jake Mehani about how Meta advertising has changed since 2014, why the creative is now the main lever, and the system Jake uses to get authentic ad footage straight from customers. They also cover what makes a great editor, why CPMs still matter, the metric Jake wishes Meta would add, and how to tell whether an agency will actually do the work.
Who is on this episode?
Brett Friedman hosts The Creative Strategy Podcast, a show about how the best creative strategists in ecommerce performance marketing come up with ideas. Jake Mehani started running Facebook ads in the summer of 2014, helped build Social Method, one of the early Facebook ad agencies, and now runs Creative Analytics, a paid social agency focused on Meta, creative testing and profitable growth.
What changed in Facebook advertising since 2014?
Jake's view is that the core of Ads Manager has not changed as much as people think. Many newer products, like Advantage+ and campaign budget optimization, mostly make the platform simpler for buyers who do not want to manage the details. What did change is that the whole industry finally accepted what Jake noticed in his first month: paid social is a creative game. TikTok pushed that message hard, and Meta followed.
That shift moved the hard problem. Getting footage is easier than ever. The new challenge is creative strategy: analyzing which ads work, coming up with more ideas, and running a steady iteration process.
What is customer generated content, and why does Jake lean on it?
Customer generated content is ad footage recorded by real buyers, not hired creators. Jake explains that he lost head to head to an account whose best ads came almost entirely from customer reviews. Those customers had answered the same short set of psychology based questions about the product and their buying journey, and the answers were edited into ads.
The reason it works, in Jake's words, is authenticity. Someone who found the product on their own and loves it sounds different from a creator who got it for free last week. It is also the same reason founder ads often perform: the passion is real.
His suggested mix for a new brand:
- Most of your content from customers. Email past buyers after the return window, ask them a handful of questions, have them record each answer as its own clip, and thank them with a gift card or store credit.
- A smaller share from creators and influencers using proven hooks and formats.
- A small slice just for fun, where you try things that may surprise you.
Recording each answer separately matters. It gives the editor building blocks they can mix, match and reorder, which is what makes fast iteration possible.
Why are editors the real bottleneck?
Jake argues that most teams ask editors to be wildly creative on every project, which is not humanly possible. When an editor works with the same style of footage again and again, like customer answers to the same questions, they master the product and the content gets better and faster.
He also says a great editor is rare and worth protecting. The difference is not which buttons they know in their software. It is whether they can see a strong moment in the footage and turn it into a hook or a new variation without being told.
Brett adds a useful point about hooks: a hook with huge attention can still pull the wrong audience if it has nothing to do with the product. Messaging pulled from real customers tends to stop the right people.
How does Jake come up with ad ideas?
He jokes that he is the world's greatest plagiarizer. In practice it means paying close attention while scrolling, saving any ad that stops him, reading industry newsletters, and studying brands in the same category. His rule of thumb: if an ad caught him, it will catch other people.
On the episode, the two break down a few ads live, including a meal replacement ad built on a classic structure (hook, then educate, demonstrate, inform, entertain, then an offer). Jake's one change would be to show the actual food much earlier, because seeing it is what made the product click for him.
He also describes a format that worked for an ecommerce food brand he worked with: the founder reviewing products over a green screen using footage and photos already on the website. It needs no new shoot and works across a large catalog.
Do CPMs matter?
Yes, according to Jake, though not in the way people usually argue. A high CPM often means you are reaching a valuable audience that many brands want. The problem is that it leaves a small margin for error: your ads have to be meaningfully better than everyone else's to win.
His bigger point is about competition. On Meta, whoever has the best ads can win market share, even against much larger incumbents. A small brand with better creative can take customers from a giant.
What about TikTok and incrementality?
Jake believes TikTok often performs better than its reporting shows, and that incrementality testing will become one of the most important skills for growth and paid social marketers. His general advice is to make your Meta spend efficient first, then expand to TikTok. He also points out that older shoppers, who hold much of the buying power, are still heavily on Facebook.
What metric does Jake wish Meta would add?
A timestamp click through rate: on average, at what second in the video do people who click actually click? If buyers usually click at second six of a thirty second ad, you know exactly what they needed to see, and you can tell an editor to make more of that. Today the platforms mostly show you when uninterested people leave, which is far less useful.
He also credits creative reporting that breaks a video into stages: stopping the scroll, holding attention through the middle, getting the click, and converting. Reading an ad in those four parts makes iteration much easier.
How do you tell if an agency will actually do the work?
Jake's advice for brands hiring an agency:
- Meet the team, not just the salesperson. An agency's reputation is often built by a small share of its people. If they are not on your account, the reputation does not help you.
- Ask who actually drove the results. Some people pushed the buttons that grew an account. Others were nearby and take credit. Ask for their personal track record.
- Ask how many accounts they handle. A great buyer spread across too many brands has very little time for yours.
- Check the account structure. Anyone should be able to open your ad account and understand the campaigns, audiences and creative from clear names and labels within minutes.
He also tells founders and finance leaders that if Meta is a major line in the budget, they need to understand it themselves, because overspending can quietly eat a large share of profit.
What is Jake reading and learning from?
Jake recommends the work of Sarah Levinger on consumer psychology, which changed how he thinks about why people buy. He prefers framing ads around the problem a product solves and the needs behind it, rather than around rigid personas.
Key takeaways
- Meta is a creative game. The algorithm handles delivery; your ads decide whether you win.
- Customer generated content, recorded as separate answers to the same questions, is authentic, cheap and easy to iterate on.
- Protect great editors and give them consistent footage so they can master the product.
- Read video ads in stages: stop, hold, click, convert. Fix the stage that is breaking.
- When hiring an agency, meet the actual team and ask who really drove past results.
FAQ
What is customer generated content?
Ad footage recorded by real customers answering questions about the product and why they bought it. Unlike creator content, it comes from people who found and paid for the product on their own, which makes it feel more authentic.
How do you collect customer video testimonials?
Email buyers after your return window, ask a short set of product and buying journey questions, have them record each answer as a separate clip, and offer a small thank you like a gift card. Include clear permission to use the footage in ads.
What is a timestamp click through rate?
A metric Jake has asked the platforms for: the average point in a video where people click. It would show exactly which moment convinces buyers.
Do CPMs matter on Meta?
They do. A high CPM usually means a valuable audience, but it leaves less room for error, so your creative has to be clearly better than the competition.
Keep reading
- The hook library: hook types that stop the scroll
- Writing a creator brief creators actually follow
- The four versions of every winning ad
- The CTSG system: Creative Testing, Scaling and Graveyard
Want this thinking applied to your account? We offer a free Meta audit, including net new reach, cumulative reach and creative reach reports. Get your free audit.