Short answer: A This or That ad puts two options side by side at very different prices, lists the promises and proof under the cheaper one, and gives the expensive one a line that reframes what you are really paying for. A pain point pricing ad opens with a question naming the buyer's problem, then compares the quick cheap fix with your product line by line on time, quality and price per use. Both work because price only means something next to another price.
Price is one of the hardest things to sell in an ad. Say it alone and the buyer has nothing to measure it against except their own wallet. Put it next to what they already pay, and it becomes a comparison they can win. This article covers both pricing formats from our board and the rules that keep them honest. The brands in the examples are made up.
What is a This or That ad?
A This or That ad is a two option comparison where the viewer is asked, in effect, "which would you pick?" One side is your product. The other is a costlier way to get a similar result. The cheaper side carries its promises and its proof (guarantee, how long it lasts, reviews). The expensive side carries one reframing line about what the extra money actually buys.
What is a pain point pricing ad?
A pain point pricing ad starts with a question headline that names the problem ("No time for lunch? No problem."), then shows a comparison table of the fast, cheap option the buyer reaches for today against your product. The rows are the things that matter to someone with that pain: wait time, quality, price per use. The question earns attention, the table does the selling.
What do these ads look like frame by frame?
The screenshots in this article are real ads from other brands, saved in Jake’s creative playbook as examples of the format. The written examples use made up brands.


This or That (static or short video):
| Beat | On screen | Text overlay | Voice |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Two options side by side | "This or that?" | "Which one would you pick?" |
| 2 | Cheaper side lights up | Its promises and proof, one per line | Reads the strongest promise |
| 3 | Expensive side | One reframing line | "What you're paying for there is ..." |
| 4 | Your product in use | The one outcome both share | "Same result. One of them I can afford to keep doing." |
Pain point pricing:
| Beat | On screen | Text overlay | Voice |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The pain in action | Question headline naming it | Asks the question out loud |
| 2 | Comparison table builds | Rows: time, quality, price per use | One line per row |
| 3 | Your product in use | "No problem." | The relief line |
Why do pricing comparisons work?
They work because of anchoring: the first number we see becomes the reference for every number after it. When the expensive option appears first, your price is judged against it instead of against zero.
Two more principles are at work:
- Framing. The same price feels different as a sticker ("$289") and as what it replaces (a bed you would otherwise pay someone to build and water). Reframing what the money buys changes how the number feels without changing the number.
- Problem first, price second. The pain point version names the pain before it names a price. By the time the price row appears, the viewer is thinking about relief, not cost.
The reframing line on the expensive side is the clever part of This or That. It does not attack the other option. It explains what you would really be paying for (convenience, a label, someone else's time), so the viewer decides it is not worth it on their own.
Which products and awareness stages suit pricing comparisons?
These formats suit products that are cheaper than a common alternative over time, or that replace a repeated purchase. They fit solution aware buyers who already know the options and are weighing cost. See awareness stages if you are unsure where your buyer sits.
Strong fits:
- Subscriptions and daily habits that replace a recurring spend
- Considered purchases that replace a service someone would pay for
- Products where price per use is far lower than the sticker suggests
Weak fits: luxury products where a higher price is part of the appeal, and products that are genuinely more expensive with no real reframe.
What does a worked example look like?
This or That on Groundswell, a raised garden bed kit at $289 with tool free corner joints and a built in drip line.
Left side, "This": Groundswell, $289. Promises and proof, one per line: - Goes together in an afternoon, no tools - Waters itself with a built in drip line - [Your real guarantee] - [Your real review count] reviews
Right side, "That": "Hiring someone to build and plumb a bed," priced at [a real local quote you can verify]. Reframing line: "What you're paying for is someone else's afternoon."
Pain point pricing on Copperbean, a cold brew concentrate where one bottle makes a week of coffee at home.
Headline: "No time for the coffee line? No problem."
| Drive thru cold brew | Copperbean at home | |
|---|---|---|
| Wait | The line, every morning | Pour and go |
| Taste | Hit or miss | Smooth, low bitterness, filtered twice |
| Price per cup | [your real local price] | [your real price per cup] |
Voice over: 1. "I was spending my mornings in a drive thru line." 2. "Now there's one bottle in my fridge." 3. "It's smooth, and it lasts me the whole week." 4. "Do the math on your own mornings."
How do you make these ads on a small budget?
- Get your real numbers first. Price per use, the alternative's real price in your market, your actual guarantee. If you do not have a number, use a qualitative row instead.
- Shoot both options in the same light and framing. For a service alternative, use a simple icon or a stock style photo you have rights to.
- Write three reframing lines for the expensive side and test them. That one line often decides the ad.
- Build the table in a design tool with large text. The price row should be the easiest thing to read.
How do you test pricing ads, and what metric shows they are working?
Test against your best current ad with the same angle, so the price framing is the main change.
- Outbound CTR tells you whether the comparison made the decision feel easier.
- Conversion rate tells you whether the price on the page matched the price story in the ad. If clicks are strong and conversion is weak, check the landing page shows the same price per use logic.
- Stop rate matters for the pain point version, because the question headline is the hook. Test several questions that name the pain differently.
We explain each stage in reading a video ad in four stages.
What mistakes and honesty rules apply?
- No invented prices. Every price, for you and the alternative, must be real and current for the market you advertise in. If it varies, say "can run" or use a range you can support.
- No fake reviews or guarantees. If you list proof under your side, it must exist.
- Compare like with like. Price per cup against price per cup, not price per cup against price per bottle.
- Do not mock the expensive option. The reframing line explains; it does not sneer. People who chose that option are often your future buyers.
- Check the page matches. A pricing ad that sends people to a page with a different price story loses them.
Key takeaways
- This or That puts two options side by side, with promises and proof on the cheaper side and a reframing line on the expensive one.
- Pain point pricing names the problem with a question, then compares the quick fix with your product row by row.
- Both work through anchoring and framing: price means something only next to another price.
- They fit solution aware buyers and products that save money per use.
- Every price, review and guarantee must be real.
FAQ
Should the expensive option be a competitor? It does not have to be. A service, a habit or a bigger purchase that solves the same problem often works better and is easier to describe fairly.
What if my product is the more expensive one? Flip the format. Your product becomes the expensive side, and the reframing line explains what the extra cost buys, such as how long it lasts or what it saves you later. Keep every claim provable.
Do I need to show exact prices? Real prices are strongest, but only if they are accurate for your market. If the alternative's price varies a lot, use a qualitative row or a range you can back up.
These pricing formats live in our creative playbook of ad formats, next to Us vs Them ads and split screen ads.
If you want to see how your ads handle price and who they are reaching, we offer a free Meta audit: a full account audit plus net new reach and cumulative reach reports. You can request one on our contact page.
Check what you learned
Tap an answer to see if you got it right.
1. Why do This or That ads work?
2. How does a pain point pricing ad open?
3. Which products fit these ads best?
Ready for the full test? Take the Creative exam and get certified. Want this run on your account? Get my free audit.
Module 5: Creative · article 3 of 44
Next: Industry vs Brand Ads: How to Compare Against a Whole Category
Previous: Us vs Them Ads: How to Make Comparison Ads That Sell on Facebook
About the author
Jake Mehani, founder of Creative Analytics
Jake has spent 15 years running Meta and paid social ads for consumer brands. Meta published his RBX Active Advantage+ case study, he taught the DMAnc Meta and TikTok ads masterclass, and he spoke at Motion's 2024 Creative Strategy Summit. His senior team runs media buying, creative and measurement like an in house team.